Protocols A group of Jews endeavors towards total domination of the blogosphere. |
Saturday, January 31, 2004 I wonder what possible motive Aljazeerah could have had in posting this story on their website: You thought of him as an Irish American Catholic. But John Kerry, Democratic presidential candidate, has Jewish rootsposted by Anonymous | 9:52 PM | "Jeopardy!" host Alex Trebek escaped injury when he apparently fell asleep at the wheel of his pickup truck and it drifted off a road, sideswiped a string of mailboxes and crashed into a ditch, the California Highway Patrol said. I wonder if Sean Connery had anything to do with it... (scroll down for the "Celebrity Jeopardy" files...) posted by Anonymous | 8:32 PM | Do we think more or less of Al Franken owing to these revelations? We're not sure.
Friday, January 30, 2004 Tonight: 8 p.m. to 11 p.m. -- Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee's Second Annual ``Flavors of the Middle East'' fund-raiser; Carriage House, 149 East 38th St.They'd better be serving kosher food. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 2:58 PM | Chabad territorial dispute in New Jersey may turn on messianic debate: However, outside observers, speaking off the record, suggested that the matter is rooted in the feud that has split the Chabad-Lubavitch world since the charismatic Schneerson died in 1994 ? a split between those who believe the Rebbe is Moshiach, or Messiah, and those who do not.According to the article, then, mainstream Lubavitch is rejecting messianism and those who seek to continue the belief/practice. We eagerly await Tolany's reaction. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 1:51 PM | One question that is relevant to ask about the Noonan/Gibson interview: How is it that Noonan is stil covering this beat when her most popular reporting on the story -- the Pope's endorsement -- turned out to be a sham? posted by Steven I. Weiss | 1:46 PM |Yeshivat Noam in Teaneck is hosting a fundraising concert with the Blue Fringe Band and Avraham Fried; two more disparate performers, I belive you could not find. The ad they've got up at OnlySimchas I find pretty funny: posted by Steven I. Weiss | 1:24 PM |On "The 5th Wheel" right now, Micah Katz, former neighbor, attended Yeshiva High school in Atlanta; dunno where he went in Israel or what have you. What is it with guys I used to know and dating shows? Is this just inevitable with the huge growth of reality television?
Mel Gibson talks the Holocaust (via Bernstein at Volokh). 'YOU'RE GOING to have to go on record. The Holocaust happened, right?" Peggy Noonan asks of Mel Gibson in the Reader's Digest for March.Bernstein says this amounts to Holocaust denial, and quotes a passage discussing Holocaust deniers' rhetoric. Thing is, the graf that Bernstein uses for comparison doesn't match up with Gibson's graf in any way. Is there something fundamentally different between the Soviet killings and the Holocaust? Yes. Are they completely undeserving of discussion in the same graf? Absolutely not. We don't know the context of the question, and I'm guessing it doesn't come after a series of questions about his father's Holocaust denying (if it had, Gibson probably would've ended the interview), so in a sense the question may seem a bit out of the blue to him. His response is pretty reasonable in this context. Noonan pushed him about the Holocaust because of accusations that the actor's father questions the attempted extermination of all Jews by Hitler. Of his dad, Gibson says, "My dad taught me my faith, and I believe what he taught me. The man never lied to me in his life."This is likely from a somewhat separate context, as well. Noonan: "Give me the headline you want to see on the biggest paper in America the day after 'The Passion' opens."Cute. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 11:43 AM | Did you guys know about Yiddish Google? (Thanks, Dave) posted by Steven I. Weiss | 11:22 AM |Two feminism/female-related events next month:
Thursday, January 29, 2004 Elder Avraham calls plagiarism on parody site Frum.net. What gives? posted by Steven I. Weiss | 10:33 PM |EphShap is starting a new blog devoted to idiocy and is seeking contributors. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 10:28 PM |After a three-week break, Jewsweek's new issue is up. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 1:25 PM |So it just occurred to me that the New York Jewish Film Festival takes place in January, and that I might have missed it; sure enough, today is the last day. Check it out, though, as individual films may soon be heading to a theater near you. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 12:07 PM |In yesterday's Reliable Source, we had a Jewish senator (Lautenberg) getting hitched, and an antisemitic Congressmember (Moran) getting engaged. At least they can agree on one thing: they both married women just over two-thirds their own age. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 10:06 AM |Shakeup at the BBC following a damning government report.
Yuter sends in a link to The Brick Testament. Of course, as we've said before, it's not only the ultra-Orthodox that have a problem with nutters.
Wednesday, January 28, 2004 "Oh, crap, we paid off the wrong rabbi." Yada finds this gossip column, which cites criticism of Madonna from a Kabbalah rabbi for her allowing hunting on her property. "Three hundred years ago, it was quite acceptable for people to shoot and hunt for food,? Ian Broadmore, head of the Kabbalah School at Hellingly in East Sussex told the London Evening Standard. ?But there is a world of difference between that and shooting birds for fun. The birds are part of creation, created by God, and as such, are part of God.?All spiritual creaminess aside, how does her Ritchieness respond to such an attack on her Kabbalistic Kredentials? "Apparently there is more than one Kaballah organization," says Madonna's rep, who points out that the group criticizing the singer is not the same one Madonna belongs to.Now where'd they leave that checkbook? posted by Steven I. Weiss | 11:17 PM | A note: please don't paste entire articles into comments; a link will do fine.
There are two cute stories out there with Yeshiva University's name in them.
You never thought it would happen, but I've been singled out as too frum by Meredith. In response to my earlier post making light of the rabbi who was upset to find restaurants claiming to be serving veal were actually serving pork, Meredith writes: There's a palpable distinction in Jewish law between sins committed be'meizid, intentionally (Brenner: "Gimme the pork chop special", Waiter: "Sure"), and be'shogeg,unintentionally (Brenner: "Actually, make that a veal tenderloin", Waiter: "Riiight"). Weiss is correct in noting that veal, a cut of meat which can be kosher if slaughtered and prepared correctly, is treyf if prepared in a non-kosher eatery. But that"s no reason to take beef (sorry, I couldn't resist) against a Jew who opts for treyf veal instead of pork. Better treyf veal than being oiver, in violation, the additional prohibition of eating a pig. When someone tries to keep one mitzvah you shouldn't go off on him for not keeping another.I'll let the hilarity of the moment settle in before responding. ... Okay, here goes: First of all, Meredith's argument operates under the assumption that the only kashrus-related issue of said slab of veal is that it is prepared in a non-kosher restaurant; in fact, just about every kashrus issue one could bring is likely quite relevant, from all the rabbinic invocations and explications of shechita and salting meat, to ones such as tzaar ba'alei chayim ("hurting living things") and basar v'chalav ("milk and meat"). Second, while, technically speaking, eating non-kosher veal and pig meat fall under different restrictions relating to kashrus, they are nonetheless part and parcel of a rather specific set of exhortations relating to those animals that may and may not be eaten and why. It is perfectly legitimate to see the Houstoner's perspective as odd, in this light. We're not comparing unassmilable categories here. Lastly, and certainly mostly, there's this exercise in gratuitous thumb-wagging: Meredith points out the difference between an action done accidentally (b'shogeg) and with intent (b'meizid); what she fails to comprehend is that this argument actually works best against her. When the Houstoner orders the veal and receives pork, he's eating pork accidentally; when he orders veal and gets veal, he's eating it intentionally. He's likely better off getting the pork by accident. As a last point, I'll note that I can't possibly be frummer than Meredith, as she uses terms like oiver, while I use the distinctly non-frum pronunciation of over. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 5:40 PM | Joseph A. D’Agostino, the associate editor of a very very right-wing conservative online magazine, Human Events, screams about the ADL, Abe Foxman and “The Passion of the Christ” ADL Continues Anti-Christian Jihadposted by Anonymous | 3:18 PM | Police believe bomb found in Tel Aviv's Azrieli complex tied to criminal activityThis is of course, as opposed to all the bombs found in the complex everyday that are not tied criminal activity. After this initial thought, I had to read the entire story to find out why my assumption about the absurd lead had to be incorrect: Police said Wednesday afternoon that the suspicious object found in the underground parking lot of Tel Aviv's landmark Azrieli Towers skyscraper complex was indeed a bomb and was probably connected to criminal figures...Okay, so now I am thinking, you are writing about a bomb that could have potentially been not just deadly but incredibly symbolic and that fact is nuanced and buried in the middle of the story!? One could argue that rather than poor journalism, this testifies to Israel's collective mentality that such an occurrence doesn’t faze them the same way it would America. If true, horrifying and enlightening. posted by Anonymous | 2:10 PM | Whew! And I thought the Orthodox community was closeted. posted by Anonymous | 2:01 PM |See no evil, hear no evil, speak no...oh, wait.
Israeli Affirmative Action Panel says 8% of civil servants must be Arab by 2007posted by Anonymous | 12:56 PM | Houston restauarants serve pork instead of veal, religious indignation ensues: "That's incredible. It's scandalous," said Rabbi Brenner Glickman, the president of the Houston Rabbinical Association and a rabbi at Beth Israel Synagogue, when I told him about the test results.This is a bit ridiculous, kind of like how when vegetarians were suing McDonalds for using a beef-derived flavoring on their French fries, everyone was joking about when a Jewish group would sign on to the suit. You have to be very reconstructionist to completely ignore all the kosher laws that would make a piece of veal at a run-of-the-mill restaurant treyf and then still reach for an idea that pig is outlawed d'oraysa. The author of the story writes, "The eating of pork is forbidden to Jews and Muslims, and deceiving them into eating it is a violation of their civil rights." The guy needs a major primer on US law. As well, doesn't he and the rest of Houston need a primer on the difference between pork and veal? I mean, if you can't recognize an expensive cut of meat, you're just wasting your money eating it (or not eating it, as the case may be). Crossposted to KosherBachelor. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 11:59 AM | I've been spending the larger part of the morning reconstructing my address book; if I should have your phone numbers, please drop me an e-mail. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 11:22 AM |Tuesday, January 27, 2004 A few people, but most recently Rabbi Uri Goldstein, sent in a link to coverage of the Nefesh conference. The headline, "Piousness may mask an emotional disorder," while nothing new to readers of The Commentator, volume LXV, is news to most of the J-comm, it seems. Today, no one disagrees with the fact that people with obsessive-compulsive disorders can easily hide among the ultra-Orthodox community, which might mistakenly interpret the individual's over-meticulous attention to the observance of the commandments as piousness.Of course, it's not just, or necessarily mostly, the ultra-Orthodox. There's plenty of unhealthy behavior at synagogues and community institutions of all stripes. It's just that among the Orthodox, a general distrust of mental health professionals (whether for actual distrust or "what people will say") leads to having more problems left undiagnosed, it seems. Professor Twerski's lecture on "Dilemmas Facing Mitzvah-Observant Families in the Modern Era," reflects the revolution that has occurred in recent years in ultra-Orthodox society, which today recognizes the fact that alongside conducting a religious lifestyle and the observance of the commandments, religious people also need mental health, satisfaction and meaning in their lives.Overall, the article has this very weird, peering-through-the-looking-glass-tone, that's rather offensive to the ultra-Orthodox; a reasonably-worthwhile read, nonetheless. ALSO: What's up with the accompanying illustration? Looks like a character in "The Rats of NIMH" or somesuch. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 10:30 PM | posted by Steven I. Weiss | 10:03 PM | Numerous people have credulously e-mailed in the link to the FrumRoller. A number of bloggers have linked to it, credulously as well.
For fear of further promoting the uber-geekiness that is Lord of the Rings fanaticisim, I was considering not linking to this source-criticism parody. Surely, we can all agree, at least this is an example of the method going too far. (via Easterblogg) posted by Steven I. Weiss | 6:32 PM |Feeling a bit nauseous...
With no advertising, save Web logs and word of mouth, the T-shirt has become the accoutrement of choice for a new breed of Jewish hipsters from Manhattan to Los Angeles. They listen to bands like the Hasidic New Wave and Hip Hop Hoodios, delight in the Yiddish-inflected humor of the magazine Heeb: The New Jew Review, and read a new raft of young, transgressive Jewish writers.If Sharon kills every last Palestinian, if the leading Jewish Americans reveal themselves to actually be Elders of Zion, if tomorrow every Jew eloped with a beautiful and morally pure Presbyterian...we'd have more chance of being forgiven than for having contributed to the growth of hipster-dom. "I think it's too soon and too inchoate to call it a movement yet, but I really do believe there is something profound and exciting going on right now with young Jews who are trying to connect with Judaism in thoroughly untraditional and in thoroughly new ways," said Joshua Neuman, 31, publisher and editor of the 2-year-old Heeb.Yeah, but none of those "thoroughly untraditional and...thoroughly new ways" involve Heeb or NYU professors claiming to be part of the new Jewish hipness. And if I see one more article referencing He'brew as something new and exciting when it's old and lame, I'll...well, I probably won't do anything except make a mental note not to judge the author's cultural judgment. <'/shudder'> (Thanks, Jennifer) posted by Steven I. Weiss | 2:37 PM | And so today, NY Daily News readers know what Protocols readers already knew: What would Jesus gross?: Mel Gibson has been accused of a lot of things since he made "The Passion," his controversial movie chronicling the crucifixion of Christ. But nobody accuses him of ignoring the Hollywood profit motive. National Public Radio is set to report today that Gibson is planning a whole line of products timed to the film's release next month, including "Passion" T-shirts and other merchandise. Gibson flack Alan Nierob tells NPR that every studio licenses film-related tchotchkes, and his client would be foolish to do otherwise.posted by Anonymous | 1:48 PM | I know that any fool can criticize, but I just can’t hold back. What the hell is up with JTA!? On Tuesday, this was posted as breaking news: ‘Fiddler’ tradition begins anewSo, you’re the JTA and you inexplicably miss all the hype for the new production of 'Fiddler' and only come up with it now, so you: A) Write an in-depth story about the production to cover for your tardiness B) Write a review of the new production C) Write a feature story on the impact of Fiddler on Jewish and general society* D) Write a little breaking news blurb hoping that no one will notice that its not breaking news Am I being too harsh or is this just plain ridiculous? *When I was taking classes in political management in Washington, I met a young lady from the Mid-West who told me that she had never met a Jew before in her life, let alone an Orthodox Jew. She then looked at me somewhat shyly and asked, “Are you like that guy on ‘Fiddler on the Roof’?” posted by Anonymous | 12:33 PM | Jewish liberals who hit critics. Add Al Franken to the list already occupied by Thomas Friedman and Chaim Seidler-Feller.
For those who've been reqesting it, our RSS feed is: http://protocols.blogspot.com/atom.xml posted by Steven I. Weiss | 10:31 AM |Monday, January 26, 2004 Hi, all.
Nissan's got a new car out, the Murano. It's kinda like a minivan masquerading as an SUV; how appropriate. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 10:18 PM |Via Radosh, the Yarmulkebra, a bra made of yarmulkes. Elderly Jewish women await the Snoodbra with bated breath. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 9:05 PM |Tonight: 7 p.m. -- Congressmen Gary Ackerman, Gregory Meeks and Anthony Weiner are scheduled to speak at a Queens Jewish Community Council forum on the U.S., Israel and the war on terrorism; Young Israel of Holliswood.Did anyone go? Tomorrow: 10 a.m. -- Ben's Kosher Deli's matzo ball eating contest; deli, 209 W. 38th St.posted by Steven I. Weiss | 8:28 PM | The Forward ran perhaps the most Chirac-sympathetic account of the headscarf issue; it doesn't quote a single dissenting voice. The story was written by a relatively-secular French Jew; is that what caused the difference? Either way, the story is not a balanced report, and shouldn't have passed the editors' desk without that perspective.
I usually make a habit of not arguing with those who are far more intelligent than I am. Today, however, I am willing to make an exception for William Safire in light of his most recent column in the Times.
But the political philosophy these two men have embraced is lopsidedly leftist: In this campaign, they have clawed their way up the greasy pole of politics with a pitch that is pure populism. Both men have risen high in Democratic polls with a brand of class resentment and soak-the-rich rhetoric rooted in the old-fashioned liberalism of Ted Kennedy.There is nothing wrong with this or the balance of Safire's piece, it is standard Conservative polemic that hits all of the right chords however, his closing line leaves me slightly puzzled: Class warfare may work in primaries but tends to backfire in the general election. Would it work for Kerry-Edwards? Ask Al Gore.Safire seems to forget that Al Gore garnered more popular votes than George W. Bush did. And many "centrist" votes that George Bush did receive were cast by people who would "want to have a drink with Mr. Bush" because he was a regular guy as opposed to preppy and stuffy Al Gore. They voted for Mr. Bush because he professed to be a Washington outsider who was going to change the culture of Washington, rescuing it from the lobbyists and special interests and giving it back to the people. Mr. Safire is dead wrong; populism is enormously, well, popular. It becomes a political liability when it is described as class warfare waged by tax-and-spend-tree-hugging-trial-lawyer-loving-baby-killers. But when packaged well, "I come from a place called hope," it is a winning formula. I am also a little bewildered as to how Safire completely ignores the Newsweek poll that has Kerry and all of his raging Populism beating George W. Bush had the election been held this weekend. posted by Anonymous | 5:57 PM | A postscript to my last post on the ADL and the Passion film. Apparently, Foxman spoke with the LA Times on Friday: his organization is preparing an 11th-hour appeal for a cinematic postscript to the movie.No word from Gibson’s people yet but rest assured they are seeing green while Foxman is screaming red. Why is this such a big issue, Foxman was asked: "Because it's now likely that more people will see his Passion in two months," Foxman said, "than saw all the Passion plays ever staged in the previous 2,000 years."I am sure that is exactly what Mel is banking on, thanks to all the free publicity… Oh, and just for shiggles... Gibson's Company Blasts Jews Who Saw 'Passion' Film 'in Stealth Mode'posted by Anonymous | 4:54 PM | Mel Gibson's 'The Passion of the Christ' Global Anti-Semitism, Israeli-Palestinian Conflict Top Agenda for ADL National MeetingThe ADL just released the media alert for its Feb. 5 - Feb. 7 National Executive Committee Meeting which is "the highest policymaking body of ADL." Topping list of important issues to be discussed at this venerable event: Mel Gibson's "The Passion of The Christ": Could It Trigger Anti-Semitism? Personally, I am little surprised that the subject is phrased in the form of a question. Surely, the ADL has not balked at telling anyone who would listen that the Gibson film is an unparalleled corpus of anti-Semitism. Looking through the riveting list of topics for this major meeting here, I found no mention of the UK poll showing that a majority of Britons don’t think a Jew can be PM. Absent too seems to be any reference to the suppressed EU survey on anti-Semitism or the much-maligned anti-Israel poll commissioned by the EU. After an exhaustive search, I even could not find any mention of a new European survey that found that “40 percent of respondents believe Jews ‘have a special relationship with money.’” Sure one can argue that all of these issues are included in the general “Anti-Semitism in Europe: Responding to the Threat” topic, but from where I sit, that is a throw away session running a distant third to the terrible threat Mad Max poses to the international Jewish community. Others may explain that this meeting is supposed to be short on substance and high on style to impress all of the vacationing donors. “Why else would it be taking place in Florida during the winter,” they may ask. Keep an eye out for Joe Berkofsky’s piece in the JTA on this subject and for Nacha Cattan’s article on the same in this week’s Forward. posted by Anonymous | 4:19 PM | So we didn't actually dialogue about this.... posted by Anonymous | 4:03 PM |Reader Shaya sends in a URL to get Free Passion promotional merchandise! Sign me up! posted by Steven I. Weiss | 3:48 PM |A Muslim, a stripper, and an American conservative walk into a bar. The Muslim wins. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 3:44 PM |After years of saying he had no knowledge of the fate of missing Israeli airman Ron Arad, Hezbollah’s leader now says Israel’s most famous PoW is in Lebanon.posted by Anonymous | 12:03 PM | Speaking of people "going down that aisle in the near future," Jewsweek Editor Benyamin Cohen got hitched a week ago. In attendance, among others, were legal expert Rabbi Michael Broyde and most-eligible-UWS-bachelor Rabbi Ezra Cohen. For those readers who attended Camp Munk or lived in Atlanta in recent decades, you'll likely recognize Rabbi David Silverman. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 11:30 AM |I just posted this at Kosher Bachelor, but I take some issues with the way the Jewish Press concludes its editorial on kosher meat and Mad Cow disease: Yet this all has even greater resonance given the attempt these days by the Forward newspaper to create the image of the Judaism of the ages as a primitive, anti-Gentile set of beliefs.Are they even trying to have their editorializing against the Forward be taken seriously? posted by Steven I. Weiss | 11:06 AM | Friend of the Elders Mikey Butler has passed away after a long struggle. I've been thinking about whether or not to post this, but I think that, just as families receive greater joy through the comments of those who know their relatives at OnlySimchas, perhaps comments here by the many readers who knew Mikey can provide solace.
I have little doubt that the comments to this post will be filled by screaming and name-calling, but there is what I think is a pretty relevant story at Nerve.com about a 23-year-old virgin female having sex for the first time. This is probably helpful for readers who are going down that aisle in the near future. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 10:31 AM |If anybody has heard a speech by a rabbi addressing Jews' relationship to non-Jews in light of the recent coverage, please contact me by e-mail. posted by Steven I. Weiss | 12:51 AM |Sunday, January 25, 2004 Yay! The Atlantic Monthly's annual annotated version of the State of the Union is up!
So Benny Morris responds to the nasty letters sent to haaretz about the his interview two weeks ago.
"In the modern age, no one has been more racist and more intolerant of "the other" - Kurd, Jew, Sudanese Christian and animist, Maronite Christian, etc. - than the Arab states. The constitution of Jordan, one of the more moderate Islamic Arab states, even includes a clause prohibiting Jews from being Jordanian citizens. The Arabs' attempt to annihilate the Jewish Yishuv [pre-state community in Palestine] in 1948 compelled Israel to uproot them from the Jewish territory. " And: "Mr. Barakeh: Enough of your hypocrisy. Only one side in the conflict in our region is under the threat of annihilation and that's the Jewish side, and you know it. So it was in 1948 (see, for example, the declaration by Azzam Pasha, Secretary of the Arab League, on the eve of the Pan-Arab invasion of Palestine, about how the anticipated slaughter of the Jews would rival the carnage wreaked by the Mongols during their 13th-century invasion of the Middle East), and so it could also be in the future. The deep hatred among the Arabs of Palestine and the proximate Muslim world for the Zionist enterprise constitutes an infrastructure for such a future genocide. There is no such hatred for anyone among the Jews or in me." Morris sounds frighteningly like a Herutnik, and I am even more frighteningly heartened by his conversion. What has become of us? posted by Anonymous | 4:13 PM | |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||